Grand Theft Auto VI is out. I have already played it front-to-back, twice. I’m visiting my uncle’s house in the suburbs for the upcoming holiday, and brought my PlayStation 5 to try and to get him to play along with me, but he refuses for two reasons:

  1. He doesn’t break the law and,
  2. Cities terrify him.

Fascinated by his disgust of this year’s hottest game, I decided to dig deeper and see where the other games in the GTA series rank for him when it comes to “Scariest City.”

Here is the full list, from least scary to most scary:

Note: My uncle says handheld games are for babies and refused to rank any of the handheld entries in the series.

8. Grand Theft Auto 2 (1999)

GTA 2 Civer
Version 1.0.0

City: Anywhere City

Era: Retro-Futuristic 2013

Scared Rating: 3/10

Scariest Thing: Readily available machine guns just laying around

The low point of the series wasn’t very scary for my uncle. Yes, he’s still terrified of the concept of being in a city surrounded by gangs and ne’er-do-wells, but when I told him Anywhere City wasn’t really based on an actual US city it kind of took him out of the whole experience. “Why make up a scary city, when there are plenty of real ones you can use?”

7. Grand Theft Auto (1997)

GTA Cover

Cities: Liberty City, San Andreas, & Vice City

Era: The 90s

Scared Rating: 3.9/10

Scariest Thing: Driving in the city

My uncle wasn’t really reacting to this one much. I even made my character fart and burp, which humor wise, I know is right up his alley (his favorite movie is The Hangover.) He started to nod off in the middle of a mission, so I drove my car onto the train tracks to explode. That woke him up and set him off into a story about one of his neighbors who was struggling with a divorce and decided to get blackout drunk and drive his car onto the tracks. His story has a similar explosive end.

6. Grand Theft Auto: Vice City (2002)

GTA: Vice City Cover

City: Vice City

Era: The 80s

Scared Rating: 4/10

Scariest Thing: Neon lights that aren’t a beer logo

Oh god, he’s singing Night Ranger. This is actually one of the few games in the series he has experience with. He’s never personally played it, but he did go over to a buddies house to watch him cruise around Vice City and listen to the soundtrack. He says he used to go to this friend’s house all the time, until some kid down the street got abducted and was never seen again. After that his parents wouldn’t let him walk anywhere. Oh god, he’s belting out Tempted now.

5. Grand Theft Auto VI (2026)

GTA VI Cover

City: Vice City

Era: The 20s

Scared Rating: 4.2/10

Scariest Thing: Twerking and falling in love

I guess my uncle really gels with Vice City. It must be the beaches or the warm weather. He’ll never admit this, but I just heard him humming Hot to Go. You know, if he’d stop letting AM talk radio and my grandparents scare the hell out of him, I think he’d be a lot happier. He says he likes Vice City but could never bring himself to live in a city. He likes knowing his neighbors. Oh god, now he’s pulling up a map on his phone of his street and is naming every neighbor as he points to their house. Lots of red markers on that map, but he says to just go ahead and ignore those.

4. Grand Theft Auto III (2001)

GTA III Cover

City: Liberty City

Era: The 00s

Scared Rating: 6/10

Scariest Thing: Living in post-9/11 America

My uncle was already familiar with Liberty City and knew immediately that he did not like it, especially once I told him this was post-9/11. He says we shouldn’t make light of tragedies unless someone had it coming. He then says Charlie Kirk, like most victims of 9/11, did not deserve what happened to him. “New York and Utah are two very overpopulated places. It’s no wonder everyone there is so angry all the time,” my uncle says before disappearing for 20 minutes to yell at his neighbor for parking in the street, across from his driveway.

3. Grand Theft Auto IV (2008)

GTA IV Cover

City: Liberty City

Era: The Late 00s

Scared Rating: 7/10

Scariest Thing: The looming 2008 Presidential election

The only thing that kept this one from ranking higher is that it came out before Barack Obama was elected President. Lord help us if Rockstar ever returns for Mamdani’s Liberty City. “You can’t just make things more affordable, that’s not how the economy works,” my uncle says before getting nostalgic about “the good ole days” of cheap gas and affordable gaming consoles.

2. Grand Theft Auto V (2013)

GTA V Cover

City: Los Santos

Era: The 10s

Scared Rating: 8/10

Scariest Thing: Taxes

I was dreading getting to the west coast entries in the series. The only people who talk more about California than the people who live there, are the people who hate California. I don’t know how he can hate the place so much. It gave him The Hangover. Oh god, he’s trying to take the controller and drive us away from the city and into Grapeseed. I yank the controller back just as another car pulls up and parks across from my uncle’s house.

1. Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas (2004)

GTA San Andreas Cover

City: Los Santos, San Fierro, & Las Venturas

Era: The 00s

Scared Rating: 10/10

Scariest Thing: Los Santos & San Fierro

My uncle won’t tell me why he’s afraid of Los Santos and San Fierro. I keep trying to drag it out of him, but he won’t budge. After a few more minutes of digging, he finally admits that both places are just full of murder and violence. Another car pulls up across the street, and it sends my uncle into a rage. He storms out the door. I hear screaming and shouting and then BANG BANG BANG. I duck to the floor and cover my head. Silence returns and then a few minutes later it’s followed by my uncle, covered in blood. “Las Venturas is awesome. More places should be like Las Venturas,” he says as sirens draw closer.



Leave a Reply

Trending

×